At that price, the room was spot on. We had no complaints, other than perhaps running out of hot water. But otherwise, it was fine and its gots its own lovely beach, so its worth the price tag.
That said, at that price, they could have done a bit better to make it really great.
1. Room amenities such as a decent coffee maker and coffer and beverages and snacks in the mini bar would be nice.
2. Check out later than 11am? Please! And they are way too rigid about this, especially since check in is at 3pm and their room cleaners dont really seem to be pressed for time - eg. Our room finally got cleaned around 5pm.
3. Reception staff are friendly enough, but a bit perfunctory and dont seem willing to engage at a 5 star level.
4. In terms of service, their Eddies Oyster was a bit the same. Politely curt and made me wait for 15 minutes to only tell me they had no availability until 2pm. Despite the fact that I was there at noon, and the first one there.
Anyway. High prices. Not 5 star, for sure. But nice stay, I suppose. Certainly one of the best and more reasonably priced places for the North Shore and the Hamptons.