The Gatsby House 8 Bedrooms

Rates INCLUDE Departure Maid Service
FREE Luxury Linen Package with All Rentals!

*Private Heated Pool coming in 2026 (delays may occur)*

HOUSE LOCATION:
Second Row
0.5 Miles South of Garden City Pier

HOUSE LAYOUT:
8 Bedrooms

6 Bathrooms

HOUSE DESCRIPTION:
Step into The Gatsby House, a breathtaking second-row beach retreat in the heart of Garden City Beach. Just a short stroll across the street from the sand and surf, this home blends the timeless elegance of a Great Gatsby beach estate with the laid-back charm of a classic surf bungalow. Designed to welcome guests of every generation, it offers both grand communal gathering areas and cozy, private nooks that ensure everyone finds their own perfect space.

With 8 beautifully appointed bedrooms, The Gatsby House comfortably sleeps up to 19 guests—ideal for family reunions, multi-family vacations, or group getaways. The home features two fully stocked kitchens with modern appliances, making it easy to cook for a crowd or let smaller groups prepare their own meals. Multiple indoor and outdoor dining areas give guests the choice to share meals together or break away into more intimate settings.

Rain or shine, the house is packed with amenities to keep everyone entertained. Gather in the private movie-viewing theatre for unforgettable film nights, enjoy retro fun with classic video game consoles, or spark friendly competition around the pool table and board games. For those craving relaxation, tucked-away reading corners and sunlit lounges provide quiet escapes from the bustle.

After a sun-soaked day on the beach, rinse off in the Polynesian-style outdoor shower, spacious enough for multiple guests at once. Fire up the grill for a casual cookout or unwind around the gas fire pit, where laughter and starlit stories come naturally. With ocean views from the second row, you’ll always feel connected to the waves—whether you’re sipping coffee at sunrise or toasting marshmallows under the night sky.

Every corner of The Gatsby House has been meticulously decorated to create a sense of nostalgia, as if stepping into the golden-age elegance of a 1920s coastal mansion, while keeping the breezy warmth of a surf-side bungalow. This unique blend of sophistication and comfort makes the home as Instagram-worthy as it is welcoming.

Whether you’re planning a multi-generational family reunion, a milestone celebration, or simply a group beach getaway, The Gatsby House offers the perfect combination of style, amenities, and location to make your stay unforgettable.

Sea Star Realty offers the most luxurious linens in the area. Including resort-quality plush towels, hand towels, face cloths, bath mats, and high thread-count sheets of superior quality for each bed in your vacation home (including sleeper sofas). In each bath, you’ll find complimentary elegant soaps. Waiting for you in your kitchen are kitchen towels, along with some complimentary items, including dish soap and a kitchen sponge. Best of all, the beds will be made prior to your arrival, and towels pre-hung in the bathrooms!