Pro: location, view, lovely decor, very clean, great deck, amount of space, privacy, proximity to necessities, distance to beach, nice beach, kitchen amply outfitted, convenient to colorful gas station, walking distance to ice cream shop, easy to reach by plane, comfy beds, no pests. The separate casita has a kitchenette, bathroom and its own thermostat.
Cons: 1 bathroom in the main house is fine for 4 but it sleeps 7; dining table only seats 4 indoors (mitigated by outdoor large picnic table and additional outdoor table and small table in sunroom), an icemaker would be nice but we bought bagged ice from the colorful gas station across the street, larger dining seating on the covered deck would be nice (again mitigated by the outdoor picnic table), plastic cups and a pitcher for mixing drinks and taking outdoors would feel more comfortable than taking real glasses outdoors, difficult to find the driveway-a sign at the road would be very helpful. The casita is slightly musty and could stand more water pressure and a hair dryer.
The Pros far, far outweigh the cons. The cons are insignificant compared to the cleanliness and the view; the convenience and privacy. It was an amazingly relaxing long weekend. We will return!!!