Spahotels in Shelter Island Heights

'Unique place but service too dependent on the individual server or concierge - some are incredible others are too slow and thereby under the level of this kind of accomodation '

'A=++'

'The building and grounds need maintenance. There's rotting window sills and rain damage on the ceiling, spots of bleach on the carpets and the doorknob of a closet came off in my hand. The TV in the room is incredibly small, the size of a computer screen. You don't come to a hotel to watch TV but like showers, you expect a nice experience. The breakfasts were ok, but not great.'

'Great stay!'

'The location and the amenities provided by the hotel was first classed'

'Love it'

'This is a beautiful top notch property that has just been renovated. Beautifully done. Very clean and well maintained. The location of the property is stellar. There's one small downside and that is it gets very windy at night, I'm not sure if that's all your long or not. We were there in early June of 2026. I would highly recommend this place.'

'Zeldzaam mooi hotel aan zee Kamers met uitzicht op zee Mooie grote kamers met balkon, Het hele hotel ademt een sprookjesachtige sfeer uit, vriendelijk personeel en heerlijk restaurant met wederom Zeezicht Enige minpuntje is wellicht de badkamer Bad met douchegordijn past niet helemaal bij deze klasse Absolute aanrader!'